Italy’s Eternal Exile: How a World Champion Lost Its Way Four Times

A World Cup Champion Strays on a Global Stage

It has been more than 11 years since Diego Godin’s header in Brazil sent the reigning World Cup champions, Italy, tumbling out of the 2014 group stages. Since then, the Azzurri have weathered a rollercoaster of near-misses, dramatic falls, and a rare European title under Roberto Mancini in 2021, followed by a relapse into crisis and controversy. The story suggests the decline is not just about a string of bad results but about a deeper, slow-moving structural shift in Italian football.

Italy’s journey through the last decade reads like a cautionary tale: a near-miss to qualify for the 2018 World Cup, a shocking exit in the Euro 2024 knockout stages, and a difficult path in the Nations League that culminated in managerial upheaval. Even as the team briefly tasted glory, the shadow of a longer-term malaise lingered, reminding us that success in football is as much about sustainability as it is about momentary brilliance.

In parallel, the club scene told a parallel story. While English clubs reinvented themselves as global brands, Italian sides leaned into short-term gains, neglecting infrastructure and the nurturing of homegrown talent. The gap between the Premier League’s financial dynamism and Italy’s traditional model widened, setting the stage for a broader national struggle to produce top-level players.

Yet there remains a spark of hope. A handful of Italian youngsters—talented players who have shone abroad—offer a blueprint for renewal. The question is whether the country’s footballing culture, governance, and investment will align quickly enough to rebuild a truly competitive national team and a thriving league. And yes, there will be jokes, because even serious football deserves a light-hearted moment to remind us not to take life—or calcio—too seriously.

Is this simply a run of unfortunate results, or a fundamental shift in who Italy is as a football nation? The answer glides between talent, structure, and the will to reform a system that once produced generations of greats. The stakes are high: a potential 16-year absence from the World Cup would be a historic embarrassment, and a powerful incentive to fix what ails the sport from the cradle to the stadiums. The truth is, this is Italy’s moment of reckoning, a chance to rewrite a narrative that has grown too long in the tooth.

Getty Images

For Italy to reclaim its place among football’s elite, it must invest in youth development, modernize stadiums, and build a sustainable model that can attract players and coaches back home. The road is not easy, but it is navigable with clear leadership and a long-term plan that prioritizes the grassroots and the domestic league’s health over quick wins on the transfer market. The next generation is watching, and so are millions of fans who deserve a national team that reflects Italy’s footballing pedigree—not just memories of past glories.

Moment of truth for Italian football is now. The reform agenda will determine whether the country returns to the world stage in 2026 or continues its slide. The path forward is clear, but the execution will require courage, investment, and a willingness to challenge entrenched habits that have held the sport back for too long.

Moment of truth for Italian football is now: can it reboot the pipeline, modernize its infrastructure, and reestablish itself as a world-class football nation, or will history repeat itself on the grandest of stages?

In the end, Italy’s football future might hinge on two simple truths: rebuild from the ground up, and stop treating young players like optional extras. Because if you don’t grow your own, you’ll end up growing old with nothing to show for it except nostalgic headlines and empty stadiums. And no, nostalgia doesn’t win World Cups—ask a 2010 South Africa veteran about that one.

Punchline time: If Italy’s football system were a smartphone, it would still be buffering on the home screen—great history, terrible loading speed. And punchline two: chasing big-name signings is like buying a fancy umbrella in a drought—great show, zero rain protection for the real problem.